|
Vol
9 Issue 1
Home
Contents
Next
Comment
|
|
|
 |
|
Following
postgraduate study in mechanical engineering design at Cambridge
University, Jon Severn worked as a product and machine design
engineer, before becoming Contributing Editor for European
Design Engineer
|
|
JON SEVERN
Stay safe, even under pressure
Having 'done some time' as a machine designer, I know only too
well the hazards presented by pneumatics; even when the actuators
are small and look relatively harmless, they can still bite! So,
as I have watched the market for safety related components grow
and evolve as machine builders have taken on board the requirements
for compliance with the Machinery Directive, it has always surprised
me how little has been announced by the pneumatics suppliers.
If you look at the developments on the electrical side, there
are now numerous safety relay manufacturers, and some of them can
offer literally dozens of alternatives. Variable speed drives and
robot controllers are now being developed with built-in safety functionality,
and let's not forget the programmable safety systems that have been
around for a few years now. Then there are safety fieldbuses: machine
builders and systems integrators are reaching the point where they
are spoilt for choice.
But what about the pneumatics? I wouldn't like to guess a percentage,
but I bet that 'most' production machinery uses pneumatics alongside
electrical equipment, yet there seems to be so little on offer apart
from dump valves (which do not eliminate all of the pneumatic hazards
all of the time). A quick search of the internet did throw up a
few safety-orientated pneumatic products; for example, Allen-Bradley's
Guardmaster range includes pneumatic limit valves (similar in appearance
to electrical limit switches), rope-operated emergency stop valves
and trapped-key interlocks. Norgren does well with a complete catalogue
devoted to "Products for Safe Pneumatic Systems" and, as was suggested
above, most pneumatics companies offer dump valves. I happen to
know that SMC has some safety related products, and other suppliers
may also have extensive ranges - but they don't make it easy to
find them.
There is, however, one safety related pneumatic system that I
think is worth of highlighting. ASi has proved to be one of the
most popular fieldbuses for certain types of application, and it
is reasonable to assume that AsiSafe (sorry, AS-Interface Safety
at Work) will do quite well too. Hoerbiger-Origa has therefore taken
the logical step of creating a second generation of its ASi-ready
intelligent actuators, to be known as Interact II. Interact is a
concept whereby an actuator, position sensors, flow controllers,
cushioning, control valve and ASi bus interface are rolled into
one, and Interact II benefits from a bus interface that is AsiSafe-compatible.
Both VDMA standard rodded cylinders and Origa System Plus rodless
cylinders are available, as well as compact pneumatic modules that
enable the concept to be extended to other types of conventional
actuator.
Fail-safe pneumatics is not a new idea; air-operated braking systems
are used worldwide on lorries and trains. Hoerbiger-Origa and the
other suppliers mentioned above clearly believe that there is a
market for safety related pneumatic products and systems, and there
is certainly something attractive about an intelligent pneumatic
actuator that can be hooked up to a fieldbus that handles both control
and safety related data. Compressed air needs to be treated with
respect; it's good to see technology being used to tame the power
source that is sometimes mistakenly viewed as being inherently safe.
Finally, a plea! This column was partly researched on the web,
which is probably how I would work if I were still designing machines.
Locating the pneumatics companies' web sites is easy enough, but
finding what you want from there can be challenging. I was infuriated
to see how few of the large companies (with, presumably, fat budgets
to pay web designers huge sums to create whizzy sites with clever
graphics), fail to include a 'search' facility. For those that had,
I could simply type 'safety' and hit 'go'. Easy. For the others,
design engineers must surely struggle to find what they want quickly.
So this is a plea, not a whinge, aimed at all technically-orientated
companies with a web presence: always include a search facility!
After all, if your site is not user-friendly, customers can easily
surf to your competitors' sites to see if they are faster to navigate.
|